The GPL and Principles

I've been enjoying reading the last few pots from Ian Bicking. This is the most recent as of this linking, and he has some thoughtful and insightful comments on the principles that underpin the GPL. A couple posts earlier he talks about the GPL vs. the permissive licenses. He's very fair, avoiding the territory of flame wars, and though I generally prefer the GPL exactly for the principles it conveys, I do understand that there are pros and cons either way, and each license has strengths and weaknesses.

Tags: open source, freedom, free software, gpl, license

Add a comment

Henry Jenkins Speaks at a Harry Potter Meeting in Teen SL

Henry Jenkins dressed as Dumbledore from the Harry Potter series speaks about Harry Potter and fan culture at a meeting in teen Second Life. Sometimes teens will complain on the SL blog that the teen grid doesn't get the same attention or love at the main grid, but Henry Jenkins is a pretty exciting guest. Nice to find this video of the meeting. There is also a linked clipped on this page of Henry's avatar dancing at the party. (Via New World Notes.)

Tags: second life, avatar, convergence, fan, culture

Add a comment

An Illustration of the Cosmology of the Grid

Hilarious illustration of the inter-working of all the various parts of Second Life. Don't let the faux 19th century academia-inspired title fool you. Or rather, let the title tell you all you need to know. :-)

Tags: second life, art, funny

Add a comment

What I've Learned: Vint Cerf

Incredible. Absolutely amazing quotes from Vint Cerf in this piece from Esquire. He plays WoW with his son, gives Al Gore props for the Internet, offers his thoughts on Second Life, and then offers up my favorite quote from the last several months of online reading:

"At the roots, people are still people."

In the context of a discussion about the Internet, this is a powerful statement, and one anyone who spends much time online can readily agree with. The Internet, in the end, is just a reflection of the people it connects.

Tags: internet, web, people

Add a comment

asleep on the job

Best photo taken of a Linden. I love that she titled it "asleep on the job" with no clue who M Linden was. :-) (Via New World Notes.)

Tags: second life, lindens, linden lab

Add a comment

collapsing geography: apoc week 13 aka the future of virtual worlds

Cory Ondrejka has some really interesting slides up from his recent seminar lectures. The thing I like most is that this "future of" talk isn't really future predicting as much as trend spotting. I think he's got several excellent predictions and ideas in these slides.

Tags: virtual worlds, virtual world development, second life

Add a comment

Archive for Mark Kingdon at ClickZ

Some old writing, but probably a good insight into the person who will be CEO of Linden Lab starting next month. (Via New World Notes.)

Tags: second life, writers, writing

Add a comment

Web space lounge -- ESC Portfolio

This screenshot of Electric Sheep's work on a virtual world in the browser is nice looking. They're using Ogoglio for the sever component and Papervision3D for the client. The look is nice certainly. When I was in Arlington this past week, Jesse demoed some Papervision stuff to me, and I was certainly impressed. This from ESC continues to impress. Of course, this is no where near what Second Life is -- a single night club in no way compares to an expansive and varied virtual world -- but it is impressive for a low barrier to entry alternative that runs in the browser.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, esc, web

Add a comment

Reuters/Second Life -- Linden Lab picks online marketing executive as CEO

Reuters breaks the story that marketing executive Mark Kingdon will become the CEO of Linden Lab. An interesting story, and though I don't know that side of the technology business well to know anything about Mark, what is mentioned here seems to hold promise for the future. It seems like a smart choice, and one that plays well to Rosedale's strengths, too. Seems like a good move, and a nice article from Reuters. For breaking SL news, Reuters seems to own that area for now.

Tags: second life, linden lab, news

Add a comment

Out to Pasture -- White Paper on VW Platform Evaluations

I find myself agreeing with Giff, even though I've had some criticisms of the virtual-world-in-a-browser posts earlier. I do think the space between the Web and the virtual world is an interesting area in which to work, and I love to see someone develop in this area. Right now, it's an all or none proposition -- you either work on the Web or in a virtual worlds. I think sites could build in some of the social aspects of an immersive 3D experience and see positive results in the blend.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, web, development

Add a comment

New World Notes: Is WindLight Frustrating Some Second Life Educators? (Updated)

I commented on this post back when it first appeared, and I only just today returned to see the follow up comments. There is some fascinating stuff in the comments, most notably Qarl's statement that he has reached out to Nicholaz Beresford and that he and other developers in Linden Lab are beginning to do something to try to improve the open source program, I would imagine in an attempt to address some of Nicholaz's concerns.

While I think it's a good move to address the concerns, I always take these kind of things with a grain of salt -- i.e. Nicholaz's statement that he's done with Second Life development. I can't tell you the number of times I've seen this sort of thing on open source mailing lists, forums, Web sites, etc. There is always some valid concern in such criticisms but I could do without all the hand waving and drama, no offense meant to Nicholaz.

Tags: second life, open source

Add a comment

Linden Lab lowers prices, estate owners rebel - Massively

For a lot of the things SL residents get upset about, this one is much ado about nothing IMHO. The main reason for this supposed "devaluing" of property is that people have bought into the metaphor that they are indeed buying land, albeit virtual land. Ownership is a great metaphor, but in this case it's causing some harm. When you "buy" land in Second Life you are really leasing server space, so any expectation of recouping the value of said lease on "sell" is wishful thinking. Granted the SL economy has worked like this often, but I don't see any way this is sustainable.

I think you can certainly sustain a model that buys an island and divides it up into smaller pieces to sell for a profit, but this notion that land has a value that remains stable or increases the same way RL land works is just not likely. At least not with a single company maintaining the servers. I'm not sure you would want to anyway, given the dynamics of a virtual economy. For example, new hardware is always going to appear; therefore; the old server will naturally devalue. Linden Lab's move makes sense to me for these reasons. It's just a shame residents can't see past the metaphor in this one case.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, virtual land, economics

Add a comment

Google App Engine - Google Code

Now that I've had a day or two to digest this, I think this plays a part in Google's Open Social efforts. One of the coolest features of App Engine is the Google account integration, which gets lost a little as people outline all the Big Table and other such features around scalability. So how do I see this playing in the larger Open Social picture? One of the hardest things about Facebook apps is trying to scale them, and Google has effectively taken this off the table. Of course, you could deploy a Facebook app from App Engine, but the integration points -- i.e. Google account integration -- fit better for Google-based social apps. And I do love that it does WSGI and smells a little like Django.

Tags: google, web apps, deployment, scalability

Add a comment

Video on Flickr!

I think this is a good move for Flickr. The player is nice looking and fits well into the photo stream. I like, too, that these videos are limited to 90 seconds, and that Flickr is trying for the idea of a "long photo." It's video in the context of what Flickr already is, rather than just another video sharing source.

Tags: photos, video, sharing

Add a comment

Here Comes the Open Source Metaverse - GigaOM

Nice overview from Wagner James Au of the leading work he saw at Virtual Worlds 08 in terms of companies and products trying to bring about an open 3D Web. While he leads with the line that any of these might make Second Life the Netscape of the virtual world movement, I don't see it. At least not with the current contenders.

Now, I'm not so naive as to think that Second Life is unstoppable. I think any technology can easily be replaced, especially when 15 years is the whole of human history we've lived on the Web. As a comparison to any other human endeavor, that's quite a short time. No one knows what tomorrow will bring, but I will tell you one thing Second Life has that none of the products profiled in Au's piece have:

Metaphor.

Second Life may be a name that leaves you open to an onslaught of first-life-less-nerds-in-mom's-basement jokes, but the name does tell you everything you need to know. And the metaphor is woven throughout the experience of the technology. As a developer I'm watching QWAQ, Project Wonderland, OpenSim, and RealXtend because these are interesting to me as technologies, but as compelling metaphors they leave me wanting, which is why I don't see any of them supplanting Second Life's dominance anytime soon.

Technology is only as useful as the concepts it embodies, and after all, it's humans that use this stuff, right? Metaphors are woven all through are computer use, and in some ways you could argue that the only fault of Second Life is that the technology doesn't live up to the promise of the metaphor. So if you really want to compete with Second Life, start thinking about the story you're telling with your technology.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, development, metaverse, metaphors

Add a comment

Second Life Simulator v1.20.0.83683 Rollout Completion - Official Second Life Blog

Havok4 is upon us. This is going to make a significant difference in Second Life stability.

Tags: second life, physics

Add a comment

Audio Stream from the House Telecommunications and the Internet Subcommittee Hearing on Virtual Worl

Just linking it up for anyone who may want to listen in. Fascinating so far. It's a Windows .asx stream, so if you're on a Mac or Linux you'll need the appropriate setup.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, congress, hearings

Add a comment

Out to Pasture -- Blog Archive -- What is a virtual world?

I've been following the things Giff is writing at the ESC blogs the last few days, mostly because I'm fascinated by the turn from Second Life to a focus on lighter, Web-based virtual world experiences. I get where he's coming from now, at least in terms of wanting to do what's possible with technology now, wanting simpler user experiences, etc. Nothing wrong with that. I am, however, still skeptical that virtual worlds via the web browser will take hold in any interesting way without something like Second Life driving it. His question on this post gets to the heart of why I feel this. He asks "what is a virtual world?" Or when he rephrases it "what does 'Metaverse' mean to you?"

To me the metaverse is not just a style of interaction with information -- information is secondary to persona. The metaverse is about my digital self. On the Web we only describe ourselves -- Genesis fan, avid reader, lover of comic books -- in the metaverse we can actually *be* this, actually show off who we are, real or imagined. I'm sure my love of comics plays into my avatar's winged look. And beyond my persona, the metaverse means location to me, i.e. my persona doing something, moving through some where. That's the "world" part of virtual worlds to me, a person in context, a person interacting, living, and working with innumerable other personas.

So for me, a virtual world is not about communication or interaction at all (though these can happen there). I think the Web gets communication and interaction really well, but I don't think the Web can do persona and place very well. At least not in the way a fully realized, 3D virtual world can. I do think one can exist quite happily with the other, one enhancing the other. But they really are two very different things, IMHO.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, virtual world development, avatar, self

Add a comment

Linux.com - After a year of open source, Second Life looks ahead

A nice "year in review" type article on open source efforts at Linden Lab. This piece covers what has already been opened as well as directions for the next year. While we won't likely see a release of the complete server source this year, the protocols of the server are being documented, as well as parts of the backend code being opened.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, open source, interoporability

Add a comment

Linden tightens the reins on its brand - Reuters/Second Life

I haven't seen much noise about this among those covering SL, so it's nice to see Reuters give it a little attention. While I totally get that this is par for the course for a company -- that if you don't protect your brand, you loose it -- I'm interested in how you square this from a practical stand point with your community. It's sort of like Google wanting to be ubiquitous in search and then getting upset when people say I "googled" for something. Lindens need SL to be *the* platform for a 3D web, but they also have to protect their interests. So where does Second Life the product end and Second Life the world created and owned by it's users begin?

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, linden lab

Add a comment

Out to Pasture - Blog Archive - Second Life for Second Life?

Hmmmm, is anyone reading this the way I am? Are ESC effectively saying, "it's been fun, but we're done with Second Life?"

Tags: second life, virtual worlds

Add a comment

A community thriving outside itself

Torley has a nice and thoughtful post on the strength of Second Life community outside SL. This gets me thinking a bit about the identification of oneself with one's avatar. I wonder as SL continues to grow in popularity -- if the notion of millions and millions of active SL users becomes a reality -- will the immersionist tendencies of the average SL user continue to prevail, or will augmentationism rule with new residents? In other words will the unwashed Internet masses flock to SL because of these vibrant micronation communities, or will SL itself just become another destination like Facebook, MySpace, etc.? My gut says there will be a blending of the two -- that having a digital self will become more common, the avatar will still be allowed to be a separate self in some ways, but the boundaries which give the impression that SL is another country will shrink a bit.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, avatar, self

Add a comment

Peering Inside: Linden Lab IPO = Epic Fail - Massively

An interesting take on what an IPO might mean for Linden Lab. This is a provocative piece, with some interesting ideas, but something about it leaves me a little meh. While I certainly understand that LL's investors are long-term investors and not sure what to make of it if an IPO suddenly came up, I'm not sure it's the apocalypse either. :-)

I've noticed this pattern with long-term SL residents -- there is this sense that the end is always near. Maybe I've been watching too many Obama speeches lately, but I'd love to see residents hold out a little bit of hope. So worst case, what if it really does all end tomorrow? Then you will have lived a full and meaningful second life and have left your mark on those around you, including your real-life self. Cheer up, that's not a bad way to have spent a couple or three (or more) years. And quite likely, your fears of an imminent end are unfounded, no matter how uncertain the day-to-day of your second life feels.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, linden lab

Add a comment

Second Life Grid Architecture Working Group Meeting 2 -- mrtopf.de

Christian Scholz (Tao Takashi is SL) does a nice recap of the second meeting of the Second Life Architecture Working Group. Complete with video and audio and Zero Linden's recap portion in just audio. I have to say I find myself agreeing with his point that the concept of an open virtual world architecture needs a single name under which we talk about these standards. I know devs -- myself included -- get nauseous with acronyms and catchy naming, but we do need a way to direct people to the docs, ideas, conversations, etc. But that's certainly a longer term issue than just getting working, interoperable servers.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, interoporability, protocol

Add a comment

Changing my Job << Official Second Life Blog

Philip Rosedale blogs about the coming changes. Short and not much different from the Reuters article. Just pointing it out for this historic day -- Philip's changing role, Philip Linden's rez day, and also my daughter's birthday. A packed Friday. :-)

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, linden lab

Add a comment

Reuters/Second Life >> EXCLUSIVE - Rosedale to step down as Linden Lab CEO

While this is not uncommon at all for startups, for some reason this took me a bit by surprise today. I imagined Rosedale staying on longer as CEO. This is an important step in the evolution of Linden Lab, and I certainly wish the company well, being the Second Life devotee that I am. I wouldn't mind seeing them take the direction Google has taken where the founders continue to be important in terms of direction, goals, and vision, but the CEO brings a level of majority to the company as it grows.

Tags: linden lab, second life, startups, virtual worlds

Add a comment

SL Forums (login required) -- (Tutorial) Photo-sourcing a face skin: Start to finish

A Second Life resident shows how to create an avatar skin from your own photo. A well-done tutorial, so if you're looking to do an avatar that looks like your RL self, this would work well. (Via Shiny Life)

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, avatar

Add a comment

Google I/O

Saving this for later... I may try to attend. Looks interesting, and of course, Google-driven web development is something I have a bit of interest in. ;-)

Tags: google, apps, conferences

Add a comment

Google Code Blog: YouTube APIs for developers and for... iguana enthusiasts

YouTube APIs get an update with lots of new features including video upload and customization options for the YouTube player. I've only glanced at the announcement, but the functionality is something my group at WPNI will certainly make use of in the next few weeks.

Tags: youtube, google, apis

Add a comment

Second Life Grid Open Grid Protocol -- Second Life wiki

Zero Linden has released the first draft of what attempts to "define the protocols by which a vast, Internet wide virtual world can operate." Very interesting to this Second Life and protocol geek, and nice to see Linden Lab make this available.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, protocol, interoporability

Add a comment

SL-LOST.COM

Recreating the Lost island virtually in Second Life. If I were a Lost fan, this would be cool, but just pointing it out for those who are. I'm looking at you Levi... don't you wish you had an SL account now? :-)

Tags: second life, lost, virtual worlds, tv

Add a comment

SiliconRepublic.com: UCD takes first steps as Second Life university

A report on University College Dublin holding a lecture in Second Life. This is one of those exciting areas to me -- educational possibilities in a virtual world. Would have been interesting to sit in on the lecture and discussion.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, education

Add a comment

Immersionism and Augmentationism Revisited

Gwyneth Llewelyn writes about the two approaches to living your Second Life -- totally immersed (hiding anything about your true identity) or as an augmentation to your real life. What's fascinating about this piece is how she compares the two camps to the "old" hacker-culture Internet and the new Facebook-social culture. She makes some excellent points about why the trend lately seems to be toward Augmentationism in Second Life, rather than the original vision of the world. Her point is that those coming to the Net these days have different expectations -- i.e. social expectations among real friends, coworkers, etc. -- than those of the early Internet or Second Life.

Tags: second life, virtual worlds, avatar, self

Add a comment